Music blog

Comic Blog Elite

Navigation Menu
a little bit of BK in VA

Posts Tagged "Comic Book Top Ten"


wonder twins
You’ve read about the best, now here’s the rest…

10. Frankie Raye

This first one is is a bit of a reach, but stay with me. Frankie was Johnny Storm’s girlfriend, and then became Galactus’ sidekick (okay, he calls them “Heralds”) because she was jealous of all of Human Torch’s adventures.  Yeah, I wanna be cool and fiery too so I’ll help sacrifice entire planets to this horrible God.

Probably John Byrne’s biggest mis-step in an otherwise perfect run on Fantastic Four.

9. Snapper Carr

Snapper was introduced as a “hip teen” to try to make the Justice League of America more relatable.

It didn’t work.  He was just annoying. And he snapped his fingers a lot.

8. Etta Candy

Maybe she wasn’t really a sidekick because she didn’t stick around too long or do much of anything. But she was a fat chick who loved candy and hung around with Wonder Woman.

7. The Wonder Twins and Gleek

Superfriends was an awesome TV show, but Zan and Jana? No. All they did was turn into birds and puddles and follow around the guys you really wanted to see.

ebony white the spirit eisner6. Ebony White

The completely racist caricature sidekick to The Spirit. I shouldn’t need to explain my reasoning here. There are lots of examples of racist sidekick characters, but this one makes my list because he was created by Will Eisner, who was in so many other ways ahead of his time.

5. Aqualad and Aquagirl.

Aqualad was stupid character based on a stupid superhero. A sidekick initially rejected by Marv Wolfman in his classic New Teen Titans comic, which was all about sidekicks. Seriously, Aqualad—-from his name to his costume—was just the most worthless sidekick ever.

And the girl version just seemed desparate.

4. Rick Jones

I’ve never liked Rick Jones. First of all, he’s a jerk, driving his motorcycle out on government property during a gamma bomb experiment. Total dick move. But more than that, he’s a professional sidekick, serving Hulk, becoming Bucky for a while, traveling with ROM the Spaceknight and two Captain Marvels….He’s just annoying. The only time I liked him was when he became a washed up, alcoholic rock star singing about his days accompanying superheroes. That was kinda interesting.

3. Roy Harper

“Speedy” never really made sense to me. He was the kid version of Green Arrow, but the only time he did anything interesting with his mentor was when he got hooked on heroin. (It should have been speed, of course.) Harper became a decent solo character, but he was a terrible sidekick. And even in his solo stories he never really did anything Green Arrow couldn’t do.

2. Kid Devil

Okay, I admit that Blue Devil was never the greatest character, but when his book came out in 1984 I enjoyed it. For the time, it wasn’t terrible. But even as a young lad who read just about every comic Marvel and DC published, I could tell this was a bad idea. Geoff Johns tried to rehabilitate the character decades later by putting him in the Teen Titans and it kinda worked—but not really.

1. Alpha

I love Dan Slott. I love everything he’s done with Spider-Man. Except this. God, was Alpha awful. Marvel tried to push him out and make him a major character, giving him solo stories and all, but the fans said no fucking way.



Yesterday, I promised you a look at the top 25 sidekicks of all time and made a good faith showing of the first 15.  Today, we finish the list.

To reiterate the rules: They have to have been an actual sidekick in a comic book—someone who didn’t appear without the main hero, at least at first and for a long time. So Supergirl and She-Hulk wouldn’t qualify. Second rule: They can’t all be Robin. Or even Batman sidekicks. Because for a guy who was supposed to be such a loner, he sure did amass a lot of hangers-on. Final rule: No animals.

10. The Legion of Substitute Heroes

A team that was created as understudies to the Legion of Superheroes, the LSHs were a group of misfits and weirdos with powers like eating stuff and hit-girl it's clobbering timeturning into immobile stone. If they were on the cover, I’d buy the comic. It was one of the only things that would make me buy Legion of Super Heroes.

9. Hit-Girl

I hear you: She’s not a sidekick! But she was. Not to Kick Ass, but to her father. And then she came into her own as the biggest badass teenage girl since Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

8. Bart Allen

What made the Bart version of Kid Flash so great? Lots of things, not the least of which was that he was a sidekick to a sidekick: Wally West, the first Kid Flash. Bart was always disgruntled, never wanting to be a kid version of an adult and always super-conscious of his role. Particularly in the pages of Marv Wolfman and George Perez’s New Teen Titans, he was the most relatable kid-version of a hero precisely because he resented being a kid. Remember when you were young? You couldn’t wait to grow up and stand on your own.

7. Wee Hughie

wee hughie becomes butcher

Was Hughie really a sidekick to the crazed, ultraviolent Butcher? Yes. The way The Boys was constructed as a comic was as an antidote to superhero books—so if Butcher was Batman, Hughie was Robin. He was also our entry point into the comic—the guy we most sympathized with with—which kind of made him the star, not the sidekick. But that was more of a narrative choice: As a character, he’s clearly a second banana to Butcher’s starring role.

And, as revealed above, by the end of the series he has taken on a lot of his boss’ worst traits…You can read more about The Boys here.

6. Francine Peters

Was Francine really Katchoo’s sidekick? Go back and read the brilliant Strangers in Paradise and you’ll see why I say she is. She serves as comedy herbie and franklinrelief when Katchoo get’s too serious or psychotic. She’s a damsel in distress. She saves the day. She provides every major sidekick function. That she’s also a love interest doesn’t mean she can’t also be a sidekick.


I’m talking about the robot butler to Franklin Richards in the wonderful all-ages comic, Franklin Richards: Son of a Genius. The book was a series of minis and one-shots, and was always charming and hilarious.

4. Sam Wilson

Maybe it’s not fair to call him a sidekick, but remember: The Falcon got his start in the pages of Captain America and for a long time the two characters shared the masthead. Remarkably, it took 20 years for him to get his first solo book—and even then, it was just a four-issue miniseries. A great miniseries, but still—way too short.

3. Dick Grayson

What?!? He’s only #3? Yeah. He was a great Robin—providing Batman with a voice of compassion that came from a place that wasn’t completely obsessed. On the one hand, he represents Batman saving his own soul—giving a father figure to a kid who lost his parents. On the other, he’s the counterpoint to Bruce Wayne, who lost his parents and had them replaced by a guy who taught him combat but was also an evil dick.

2. Tim Drake

first appearance tim drake robin

I know, I know: Two Robins at the top of my list? What can I say? The original sidekick is still the best. And I could never do better than Chris Sims at explaining why Tim Drake is the best Robin ever.

1. Bucky Barnes

Could there really be any doubt that this is who I’d pick? Of course not. Bucky Barnes was great as a sidekick, especially in the retcon flashbacks by Ed Brubaker where he was revealed to be a violent assassin—someone who took care of business even Captain America didn’t know about. But he was also great when was fleshed out has his own character, first as the sinister Winter Soldier and then eventually taking over the mantle as Captain America.

TOMORROW: The Worst Sidekicks of All Time!



batman is gay with robin

List time again! Today and tomorrow, the top 10 comic book sidekicks of all time, according to me. Now, the rules are: They have to have been an actual sidekick—someone who didn’t appear without the main hero, at least at first and for a long time. So Supergirl and She-Hulk wouldn’t qualify. Second rule: They can’t all be Robin. Or even Batman sidekicks. Because for a guy who was supposed to be such a loner, he sure did amass a lot of hangers-on. Final rule: No animals.

And a caveat: These are my personal favorites, not necessarily the most important sidekicks—or even the most relevant. If you disagree with me, drop a comment and tell me why!

brat pack by rick veitchWe’ll start out, today, with #s 25-10, and then you can come back tomorrow and see the top 10…And then, some of the worst sidekicks of all time!

25. The Brat Pack

It’s hard to find Rick Veitch’s comic about sidekicks who serve as commercial products, and I’m going by memory, but as I recall it was excellent. It won an Eisner. But since I can’t do more research, it’s just placing at #25. Interestingly, it’s one of two “teams” of sidekicks you’ll see on this list. Can you guess what the other one is?

Hint: It’s NOT the New Teen Titans.

24. Obelix

Sidekicks essentially perform two functions: Humor or straight man. Obelix was the classic humor version. Costello to Asterix’s Abbot.

23. Frenchie

frenchie moon knight

Less a sidekick and more of a chauffeur, but Moon Knight’s helicopter pilot was a fan favorite. Also, one of the first semi-major gay characters in comics.

22. Kato

Speaking of drivers, here’s Kato. There have been comics about him, and the comics are actually often better than the TV shows, so he gets on the list. Chewbacca doesn’t get on my list, so take this one instead.

21. Mephisto

Sure, nobody thinks of him as a sidekick but the dude used to step and fetch for Thanos. Good times.

20. Amadeus Cho

AKA “The Seventh Smartest Person in the World.” What was cool about Cho’s period of service as a sidekick to the Hulk was that he did something nobody else ever did. Hulk went through lots of sidekicks and hangers-on, but through it all he resented puny banner. So his sidekicks were never all that smart. And his run with Hercules was terrific, too.

19. Arthur

Arthur, AKA The Moth, served alongside the lunatic hero, The Tick. Arthur was more than just a “straight amn sidekick,” though, he kept his bungling, egomaniacal hero out of trouble in the same way 99 always looked out for Maxwell Smart.

18. Wong

wong the manservant

An appearance by Dr. Strange’s Chinese manservant was always the highlight of Strange’s stories for me. I can’t explain why. He even broke the golden rule of Asian sidekicks by not being a karate expert!

17. Hydra Bob

Remember how I said that some sidekicks fulfill a necessary humor function? Well, Deadpool was already funny. Bob is his punching bag, his whipping boy, a character who does nothing but get the crap beat out of him, issue out of issue. If Deadpool was in South Park, Bob would be Kenny.

16. Harley Quinn

Sorry, fans, but she doesn’t rate higher than this for me. It’s pretty rare that I read her in a comic and enjoy her. Loved her on TV, but this is a comic book blog—not a cartoon one. At the same time, I love the concept of a girl for Joker. A crooked lid for a crooked pot.

15. Captain Haddock

More so than any of the other characters who hung out with Tintin, Captain Haddock was a star. The drunken sailor deserved a spin off. Written by Garth Ennis. Hey, it’s not too late.

14. Hobbes

Calvin and Hobbes was a comic, so this counts. We all know that Hobbes was imaginary, just a tool of Calvin’s id, but he seemed so alive to us as readers. In fact, when my son was eight and read every single Calvin and Hobbes book over and over, he insisted Hobbes was real and not just a stuffed animal. Oh, and I know I said no animals—but he’s a stuffed doll, not an animal.

13. Cheeks the Toy Wonder

Speaking of stuffed dolls, in his first solo book Ambush Bug got himself sidekick: A toy doll that he found in the garbage. I loved this book, and never forgot Cheeks. It was good to see Bug having someone he actually cared about, since other than that he was basically a witless psychopath.

12. Lockheed.


Again: I know I said no animals! But Lockheed’s a dragon, not a pet. And he was a great sidekick for Kitty Pryde.

11. Jimmy Olsen

I hesitated before putting Jimmy on this list because he’s not really a sidekick. He’s more like a damsel in distress, or a supporting character. But I remember his solo book titled “Superman’s Pal, Jimmy Olsen.” That sure sounds like a sidekick to me.

Tomorrow: The Top 10!



I love Daredevil.  Love, love, love him.  I’ve read every single issue of Daredevil ever published, in fact. 

He’s also my youngest son’s favorite character.  He’s got a show.  And it’s fantastic. 

I know I’ve done a top 20 DD stories of all time.  (And a top 10 post on Kingpin comics.)  But a lot has happened since I made my first list.  For one thing, I’ve read every single issue of Daredevil ever written since I wrote that list.  For another, Mark Waid, one of the industry’s most innovative storytellers, took over Daredevil and moved the character in a direction he’d never gone before.  And Brian Michael Bendis and Alex Maleev returned to the character with End of Days.  And perhaps most important of all, Comic Books Should Be Good published their “best 75 DD stories” list, based on reader input.  So, lots of reasons for my reexamination.

For giggles, I’m going to also publish in my new list where the book fell in the CBSBG reader poll and in my old list.  Nerd cataloging fun!  As I did this list, I found my old numbers getting really jumbled up.  It’s so hard when you’re looking at stories as great as these to decide what goes where.  So, some of this is really random—based on what I remember right now as I organize the list.

Let’s start with the ones that didn’t make it back into my list, and then launch into the top 20.  No.  Wait.  Let’s make it 25.  Because you can never have too much Daredevil.


Daredevil vs. Doctor Doom (Fantastic Four #39-40 & Daredevil #37-38).  Previously: 13; CBSBG: 43.  Lots of people like this one, and the one where DD and Doom switch bodies, but in the grand scheme of great tales, I can’t put these in my top 25.  They are a lot of fun, though.

Pawns of the Purple Man (Marvel Team-Up Annual #4).  I still love this comic, but it’s really a team up with Power Man, Spidey, Iron Fist, etc.  It’s not really a DD story…



I don’t usually like horror comics, but this year I found myself reading quite a few.  Many were good: Revival, Greg Rucka’s Veil, and American Vampire: Second Cycle (not as good as the first cycle, but still worth a read).  Even George Romero’s Empire of Dead, published by Marvel (but not taking place in any Marvel universes), was much stronger than expected—largely due to Michael Lark’s art.  And Rachel Rising continues to be excellent, but since it’s on my “best of the year” list I didn’t think I should list it here.

So, lots of good horror comics in 2014 and five truly exceptional ones….


5.  Bad Blood (Dark Horse). 

A surprisingly character-focused by Jonathan Mayberry and Tyler Crook about a (relatively incompetent) vampire hunter with cancer-filled blood, and his goth-stripper girlfriend.

4.  The Wake (Vertigo).  

This was a horror comic in the same way Alien was a horror movie.  Scott Snyder and Sean Murphy’s story seemed to be a tale of dystopian sci fi futurism, but (ahem) under the surface, this book about underwater mysteries was a horror story and a mystery.  The first arc, which came out in 2013, was definitely the scarier of the two—the wrap up takes place in the light, where the first six issues took place in the depths of the sea, but since it wrapped in 2014, I’m putting it on this list.  Most folks will read it in trade, anyway.

3.  Red Rover Charlie (Avatar).  

A zombie apocalypse story told from the point of view of dogs, written by Garth Ennis.  The only thing that could have made this better is if it had taken place in his “Crossed” universe.  Oh, and by the way, it’s not the first animal comic that nearly made me cry (We3 was first).

2.  Afterlife With Archie (Archie Comics).  

No, this wasn’t just a gimmick: It was good.  No, it was actually excellent.  The only reason it’s not ranked #1 is because it wasn’t really “scary,” and wasn’t really trying to be.

1.  Nailbiter (Image). 

This great mystery reads like a Dexter spin-off.  It’s about an investigation in a town known for birthing serial killers.  In a one-off issue, a pregnant woman comes to the town because she wants her baby to born there and grow up to the next Jeffrey Dahmer, so she can be famous.  That simple story was fantastic, and captures the essence of the ongoing story as well.

Next: The movement in comics is MORE #1s!  So, we’ll look at the best #1s of 2014…



Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 10 other subscribers